POTTSTOWN PA – A former Lower Pottsgrove (PA) Township commissioner, who hopes to regain a seat there during next month’s general election, has asked the Pottsgrove school board to reconsider disciplinary action against a Pottsgrove High School student accused of attending a recent football game in an intoxicated state.
Stephen Klotz of New Kepler Road, Pottstown PA, made his plea to the district Board of School Directors during its meeting last Tuesday (Oct. 11, 2011), in an effort to reverse or at least lessen the discipline against the student who was not identified by name but who was said to be a male athlete.
Directors agreed they would take a closer look at disciplinary policy, and the board’s Policy Committee scheduled a meeting next Tuesday (Oct. 25) at 6:30 p.m. in the district offices, Kauffman Road, Pottstown PA, for that task.
Under the guidance of district Solicitor Kyle Berman, however, they limited discussion of the case’s specifics and pointedly made no promises about over-turning decisions in it.
Klotz is not related to the student or his family, he told board members, and said he appeared before them primarily as someone who knew those involved and wanted to be of help. He argued the district policy regarding intoxication and banned or controlled substances should be applied “on a case-by-case basis” rather than broadly meted out.
The policy, according to district Superintendent Dr. Bradley Landis, can involve punishments up to expulsion, attendance at night school rather than during the day, and required counseling.
Although various laws demand privacy in such situations, it was revealed – to Berman’s obvious dismay – that the student had agreed to attend Pottsgrove’s “Twilight Program” night school, staffed by its own teachers, for an unspecified period. “I think we’ve been very sensitive in the matter,” Landis said.
“But are we setting this kid up for failure?,” Klotz countered. He suggested that a single infraction should not jeopardize the student’s opportunity to obtain a scholarship or attend selected colleges. “Every kid should have the right to a better education,” he added, “and I really feel you have to look at this policy. I think it’s a mistake.”
Directors and administrators made it clear they did not.
“We’re not turning our backs on this child,” board President Michael Neiffer observed. “We’ve provided several options” for discipline, he added, and the student and the district agreed on one. Pottsgrove’s zero-tolerance policy in such circumstances was worthwhile and protected all involved, he indicated.
Director Fred Remelius went further. “There’s been a lot of tragedy in this school district and others regarding alcohol in the last couple of years,” he reminded Klotz, in a reference to automobile accidents that claimed students’ lives. “The headlines in the local paper are filled with them. There are very, very serious consequences that go along with that,” he said, and said dealing with improper student behavior is one way to address them.
And high school Interim Principal Yolanda Williams objected to Klotz’s characterization of the policy as one-size-fits-all. “It’s not a blanket approach to each kid” she said.
After about 20 minutes, Berman stepped in again. “This school board meeting is the venue” to address directors, he told Klotz, “but not the venue for a back-and-forth discussion of the specifics. It’s not a place for this give-and-take.”
Both board members, some of whom are running for re-election in November, and Klotz, who is running for election to the Lower Pottsgrove Board of Commissioners, took the hint and stopped talking.
Related (to the Pottsgrove Board of School Directors’ Oct. 11 meeting):